The Encyclopedia of the Sword Review

Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)Are you looking to buy The Encyclopedia of the Sword? Here is the right place to find the great deals. we can offer discounts of up to 90% on The Encyclopedia of the Sword. Check out the link below:

>> Click Here to See Compare Prices and Get the Best Offers

The Encyclopedia of the Sword ReviewThis book contains a voluminous amount of interesting information on sword history and fencing. Unfortunately, it is also teeming rather horrendously with misconceptions, familiar myths, historical inaccuracies, and pure fiction. The author only used the barest references as his sources, some terribly outdated to the 1920's! He even omitted the major recent works of world experts and it really shows. The author is to be commended for his efforts, but his one-man show missed a tremendous amount of fundamental material on the attributes of sword types and wasted effort on frivolous entries.
Throughout, the author's point of view is exclusively that of a modern instructor of sport fencing who is enthralled not with our martial heritage but with choreographed Hollywood swordplay. His inexperience with medieval fighting manuals and with medieval swords in general shows clearly. In this way it distorts much of what would be useful to today's sword enthusiasts and students of historical medieval & renaissance swordsmanship. The amount of irrelevant material included is matched only by the amount of relevant material that was left out, especially on medieval German and Italian sources, and renaissance English ones. The work excludes several major categories of European sword forms and blade types while seeming to come up with altogether new ones. The material on 19th century German swords and Mensur are full of holes and errors. Also, the entries on Japanese swords and swords arts (as well as those on Chinese) are erroneous and insulting in their simplistic.
Only those who have never before encountered or studied anything substantial on the history of swords and fencing will be impressed with this book or fail to notice its serious and glaring discrepancies. It's certainly worth pursuing, but if you can afford to get the book, do so just to serve as a bad example of limited, biased research. Otherwise, serious students of the sword would be far better off to start their own library of primary! sources rather than paying $75 for this.The Encyclopedia of the Sword Overview

Want to learn more information about The Encyclopedia of the Sword?

>> Click Here to See All Customer Reviews & Ratings Now